Add How PPP loans come up in due diligence: what buyers will ask

2026-10-20 20:23:04 -04:00
commit 8dc6a02216
1 changed files with 183 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,183 @@
 <br>Whether a buyer treats your PPP loan as debt or as a settled item depends on one question: has the lender and the Small Business Administration (SBA) finished forgiving it? That single criterion shapes how PPP loans come up in due diligence, from the first data request to the price discussion. Answer it before a buyer asks, and the rest of the review gets much simpler.<br>
 Start with the loan's status, not its size
 <br>Before you think about how a buyer will react, sort out where the loan stands today. A Paycheck Protection Program loan can sit in several different states, and each one leads to a different conversation. The loan might still be in its repayment period with no forgiveness application filed. An application might be pending with the lender. Forgiveness might have been approved in full, approved in part, or denied. Each state changes both the balance you owe and the story you can tell.<br>
 <br>Start with a few plain questions. Did we file a forgiveness application? If so, did the lender send a decision, and does that decision cover the whole amount? If the lender has not decided yet, when did we last hear from them, and what did they say? Write the answers down with the dates from your own records. A vague answer like "we think it was forgiven" will not survive a buyer's review, and it may create doubt about everything else you say.<br>
 <br>Some background helps here. The PPP was created under the CARES Act to help small businesses keep staff on payroll during the pandemic. Lenders made the loans, and the SBA oversees forgiveness. The program no longer accepts new applications, so for most owners the question is not whether to apply. The question is how to close out a loan that already exists, and how to show that the close-out was done correctly.<br>
 <br>Forgiveness is not automatic. The borrower submits a forgiveness application to its lender, the lender reviews it,  Image_Comment	Thanks for laying out how fractional CFO support can fit into a growing business. Reliable reporting for the board is easier to build early. Looking forward to a follow-up on this topic. and the lender passes it along to the SBA. The forgiven amount depends on how the loan proceeds were used, which costs qualified under the program rules, and whether the documents support those costs. A loan that looks fully forgiven on a portal screen can still raise questions if the records behind it are thin. That is why buyers care about status before they care about size.<br>
 <br>This sounds like a lot to track, but the status question is useful. Once you know the state of the loan, you can name the next step, the person who owns it, and what to send a buyer. Many first-time fundraising founders find this clarifying, because investors will ask a version of the same question during early conversations, even when the loan is small.<br>
 <br>A one-page status note is enough to start. Include the lender's name, the original loan amount, the date of each decision letter, the forgiven amount to date, the remaining balance, and a short list of open questions. Update the note every time a letter arrives or a payment is made. When someone asks about the loan, you can hand over the note and then point to the documents behind it.<br>
 Where PPP loans show up in a buyer's first review
 <br>Buyers rarely start with the loan itself. They start with the balance sheet, the debt schedule, and the cash flow statement, then look for items that do not fit the pattern. A PPP loan can appear as a liability while forgiveness is pending. It can appear as income when forgiveness is recognized. It can also show up in the cash flow statement through the original proceeds or later repayments. A buyer's accountant will look for each of these places and check that they tell the same story.<br>
 <br>You will hear a few terms during this stage. Due diligence is the review a buyer or investor performs before closing a deal or committing money. A data room is the shared folder where the company posts documents for the buyer to read. Quality of earnings is an analysis of whether reported profit reflects the ongoing operations of the business. You do not need to become an expert in these terms, but you should know what they mean before the first call, because they will shape the requests you receive.<br>
 <br>The first request list usually includes the loan agreements and debt schedules, the lender's correspondence, the forgiveness application as filed, and bank statements that show when the money arrived. The buyer's accountant will try to tie the loan balance on your balance sheet to the lender's statements. If the numbers do not tie, the next question will be why. Sometimes the answer is simple, such as a timing difference. Sometimes it signals a bookkeeping gap that the buyer will want to examine more closely.<br>
 <br>Equity investors ask about the loan too, though for different reasons. They want to know how much runway the company has and whether a loan will be repaid from cash that would otherwise fund growth. A balance that looks small can still matter if repayments begin during the period the new money is supposed to cover. That is why the loan belongs in the same conversation as the forecast, not in a footnote.<br>
 <br>Here is a simple example. Imagine a hypothetical manufacturer, invented for this illustration, that shows a $200,000 loan balance in its debt schedule but only $180,000 in its general ledger. The gap came from a partial forgiveness entry that was posted to the ledger but never updated in the schedule. A buyer's accountant can find that gap in an afternoon, and the founder then has to explain it under time pressure. Before the data room opens, ask your bookkeeper to walk the loan from the lender statement to the ledger to every financial statement that mentions it. Fix any mismatch, and write a short note [Image_Comment	Thanks for laying out how fractional CFO support can fit into a growing business. Reliable reporting For the board is easier to build early. Looking forward to a follow-up on this topic.](https://Venturegrowthpartners.com/locations/massachusetts-boston-fractional-cfo-services/) any difference that has a valid reason.<br>
 Choosing between debt treatment and a closed item
 <br>The central decision is how to present the balance. You have two broad options. The first treats the loan as open debt, where the balance is still outstanding and counts as a liability. The second treats the loan as a closed item, where forgiveness is final, documented, and the liability has been removed from the books. The criterion that separates them is simple: do you have a final written decision that covers the amount you are presenting as closed?<br>
 Option A: Treat the balance as open debt
 <br>This option fits when no final decision exists, when forgiveness is still under review, when only part of the loan has been forgiven, or when an application was denied. In each case, the remaining balance is a real obligation that the company must repay under the loan terms. A buyer will usually count that balance as debt, or as a debt-like item, when setting the price. A debt-like item is any obligation that reduces what the seller receives at closing, even if it is not labeled as debt in the financial statements.<br>
 <br>Treating the balance as open debt is not a failure. It is an honest description of the situation. The work is to present the balance clearly, with a repayment schedule and the status of any pending decision. Ask yourself what the remaining balance is, when repayments begin, and whether the loan has a change of control clause that would affect a sale. Those answers keep the conversation grounded in facts rather than assumptions.<br>
 Option B: Treat the loan as a closed item
 <br>This option fits when the lender and the SBA have issued written decisions showing full forgiveness, the application file is complete, and the accounting entry that removed the liability matches the decision. In this case, you present the forgiveness letter, the final application, and the journal entry that closed the balance. The buyer then focuses on two questions: whether the accounting treatment is correct, and whether any gain from forgiveness should be excluded from ongoing earnings.<br>
 <br>Before you choose Option B, check five things in order. Is there a final written decision? Does it cover the full amount? Are the supporting records complete? Does the accounting entry match the decision? Has your counsel reviewed any obligation that remains, such as notice requirements? If any answer is no, lean toward Option A until the gap is fixed. A closed item presented too early is one of the most expensive errors in this topic, and the final section explains why.<br>
 <br>The table below compares the two options across the attributes a buyer is most likely to examine.<br>
 Attribute
 Open debt (not finally forgiven)
 Closed item (forgiven and documented)
 Current status
 Application pending, partially forgiven, or denied
 Final written decision covering the full amount
 Balance sheet
 Liability remains, with repayment terms shown
 Liability removed, with the entry matching the decision
 How a buyer usually treats it
 Possible debt-like item in price negotiation
 Usually reviewed for accounting and for any gain in earnings
 Documents to bring
 Loan agreement, repayment schedule, status letter or application
 Final forgiveness letter, filed application, supporting records, journal entry
 Cash question to answer
 When repayments start and how they fit the forecast
 Whether any remaining obligation or reporting duty still exists
 <br>Partial forgiveness is the hard case, and it deserves its own treatment. Present the forgiven portion as closed, with its letter and entry, and present the remaining portion as open, with its status and schedule. Do not blend the two into one line without explanation. A buyer will read a blended number as a sign that you do not yet understand your own loan, even if you do.<br>
 The documents a buyer will ask for, and where to find them
 <br>Buyers ask for documents in a predictable pattern, so you can prepare the core set before anyone requests it. The most useful habit is to ask one question about each item: can we produce this within a few days without digging through old email? If the answer is no, the item belongs at the top of your preparation list. A good starting set includes the following.<br>
 The original loan agreement and promissory note from the lender
 The loan application and the payroll and cost figures submitted with it
 The forgiveness application as filed, with its supporting schedules
 The lender's and the SBA's written decisions, including any reduction letters
 Bank statements showing receipt of the proceeds and how the money was spent
 Payroll registers and the quarterly payroll tax filings for the covered periods
 <br>Each item has a job in the review. The payroll registers and tax filings tie to the payroll costs used in the forgiveness calculation, so a buyer can check whether the numbers reconcile. The bank statements show the trail from the lender to the company's accounts and then to the expenses. The decisions prove the outcome. Without the connecting records, the decisions are just letters, and a careful reviewer will want to see the math behind them.<br>
 <br>Retention matters as well. Keep records for as long as the SBA and your lender require, and expect buyers to ask for them for years after the loan closed. Those requirements are the kind of detail you should confirm with your CPA or counsel rather than assume from memory. A folder with dated filenames, a one-line description of each file, and an index sheet will save hours when a request arrives.<br>
 <br>Buyers may also ask whether the company qualified when it applied. That answer depends on the eligibility rules in place at that time and on whether affiliated businesses were counted. An ownership change or a related company can complicate the answer, so the question should go to your counsel, and the answer should be written down. Do not rely on a verbal explanation from a bookkeeper or a sales conversation with a buyer.<br>
 <br>Build the folder before the buyer asks for it. Create one folder per loan, add an index that lists each document with a short summary, and keep an open-items list at the bottom. For each document, name the person responsible for keeping it current and note when you last checked that it exists and matches the ledger. When you share files in a data room, upload reviewed copies with a short cover note rather than raw exports, so the buyer can see what each file proves.<br>
 How forgiveness changes earnings and the price
 <br>Forgiveness can create an accounting gain. When a liability is removed, the company may record income in the period when the removal is recognized. A buyer preparing a quality of earnings analysis usually removes one-time items from the earnings used to value the business, because a one-time gain does not show what the business will earn in normal operations. The same logic applies to other non-recurring items, so a forgiveness gain is treated as a reason to look more closely, not as a sign of stronger ongoing profit.<br>
 <br>The payroll costs covered by the loan were real expenses in the period they occurred. Buyers look at whether the cost base reflects normal operations after the program. If headcount, wages, or other costs changed around the time of forgiveness, the buyer will want to understand why. You can answer that question well if you can show the staffing history, the payroll records, and the reasons behind any changes.<br>
 <br>Price is the next step. Many deals set a price based on enterprise value and then subtract net debt to reach what the seller receives. Net debt is the total of the company's debt minus its cash, with some agreed adjustments. An outstanding PPP balance may be treated as debt or as a debt-like item in that calculation. If you expect the buyer to ignore the loan, that expectation should be tested early, because it is a negotiation point rather than a settled fact. Ask how the buyer intends to treat it in the draft purchase agreement.<br>
 <br>Working capital can also be affected. Working capital is the cash and short-term balances a business needs to run day to day. If loan timing or a large repayment shifted cash on the balance sheet date, the buyer may argue that the working capital target should be adjusted. Working through this in advance helps you avoid a late surprise when the closing statement is drafted.<br>
 <br>Here is a hypothetical example, not a real company. A services business reports $1.2 million in operating profit for a year, and that figure includes a $300,000 forgiveness gain recorded in the same period. A buyer's analysis would remove the gain, which lowers the earnings figure used for valuation to $900,000 before any other adjustments. The example is only a way to see the mechanics, because the actual effect depends on the buyer's method, the deal terms, and the rest of the business. No outcome is promised.<br>
 <br>Before the first valuation discussion, ask a few questions. Which of our reported gains are one-time? Does the buyer plan to treat any remaining PPP balance as debt? Would a partial forgiveness change the working capital target? Keep the answers in a short model or a memo so the numbers and the explanations stay consistent. Consistency matters more than any single number, because it shows the buyer that the business understands its own results.<br>
 Building the loan into your cash forecast
 <br>Your 13-week cash forecast should show the loan's effect week by week. A 13-week cash forecast is a short-term model that lists expected cash receipts and payments over the next quarter, updated as actual results come in. If loan repayments begin in a given week, they belong on the outflow side along with any interest. If forgiveness is pending, the forecast should not assume the cash relief until the written decision arrives. A pending decision is a possibility, and the forecast should treat it that way.<br>
 <br>A practical method has five steps.<br>
 List every loan payment date in the next 13 weeks using the lender's schedule.
 Mark any week when a forgiveness decision could change the balance, and do not book the relief until the decision is in writing.
 Run a scenario where forgiveness is denied or reduced, and see the cash effect in each affected week.
 Compare the forecast with the lender's statement each month, and correct any difference.
 Show the buyer or investor the base case and the downside case side by side.
 <br>A driver-based model links the loan to the factors that drive it. A driver is an input that changes the output, such as payroll headcount, eligible costs, or the interest rate on the balance. If forgiveness depends on payroll and headcount, the model should reflect that relationship, so you can see how a change in staffing would affect the cash picture. Even a simple version is more useful than a single fixed number, because it shows the reasoning behind the forecast.<br>
 <br>Investor reporting should make the loan easy to find. A monthly report that lists the PPP balance, its status, and the expected next step lets an investor understand the situation without digging through the appendix. If an investor has to ask basic questions about the loan, the report is not doing its job. Clear labels and a one-line status for each item usually solve the problem.<br>
 <br>Ask a few questions as you build the model. What is the minimum cash we need if forgiveness is denied? When would repayments start if forgiveness is reduced? Do loan repayments fall in the same weeks as payroll, and if so, how much room is left? The answers will show whether the business can handle the downside without an emergency decision. They also show whether the forecast is realistic enough to share with someone who will invest money based on it.<br>
 <br>Finally, update the forecast as letters arrive. A forecast is a working document, not a promise. When a decision comes in, replace the scenario with the actual outcome, note the date, and explain any change in the assumptions. Buyers and investors trust a forecast that gets revised openly more than one that never changes.<br>
 Reading the loan agreement and aligning with your CPA or controller
 <br>The loan agreement holds the rules that a buyer will care about. Look for the repayment terms, the default provisions, any notice requirements, and the change of control language. A change of control clause describes what happens if ownership of the company shifts. Some lenders require notice or repayment in that case, while others have no effect on a sale. Do not guess which one applies to your loan. Read the clause and confirm its meaning with your counsel.<br>
 <br>When you meet with counsel, ask a short set of questions. Does this loan need to be repaid, consented to, or disclosed at closing? Who must be notified, and by when? Does a sale affect any forgiveness that is still pending? Does the answer change if only part of the company is sold? Bring the loan agreement and your status note so the discussion starts from facts rather than memory.<br>
 <br>Your existing CPA or controller owns the books and the tax filings. Strategic finance support can help with forecasts, diligence preparation, and investor reporting, but clear roles prevent two people from changing the same entry. Before any data room opens, agree on who records forgiveness in the ledger, who signs off on the disclosure, and who answers the buyer's accounting questions. Those three decisions prevent most of the confusion that comes from overlapping work.<br>
 <br>A short meeting with your CPA before diligence starts is a good use of time. Bring the status note, the document index, and the list of open questions. Ask the CPA to confirm the accounting treatment, and ask counsel to confirm the legal reading of the loan terms. Keep the two conversations separate, because they answer different questions and rely on different expertise.<br>
 <br>Here are a few questions to bring to that meeting.<br>
 Has the forgiveness entry been posted in the period the decision supports?
 Does the debt schedule match the general ledger and the lender's latest statement?
 Which financial statements disclose the loan, and do the notes say the same thing?
 Who will answer a buyer's accounting questions, and who will handle legal questions?
 <br>Remember that a named professional does not guarantee a particular result. A CPA, controller, or advisor can make the records clearer and the process more orderly, but the lender, the SBA, and the buyer each make their own decisions. Your job is to know what each party owns and to keep the documents that support your position.<br>
 The costliest mistake: presenting an unresolved forgiveness as settled, and how to avoid it
 <br>The costliest mistake in this topic is calling a loan forgiven before the paperwork says so. Founders often hear the word from a lender call, a portal status, or a colleague, and then repeat it in a board update or a data room cover note. The buyer then asks for the decision letter. If the letter is missing, or if it covers only part of the balance, trust drops quickly. The buyer may reprice the deal, add conditions, or ask for protections in the purchase agreement, such as a specific indemnity or a holdback of part of the price. Each of those outcomes can reduce what the seller receives, and none of them is guaranteed to be avoided once the trust is gone.<br>
 <br>The mistake usually comes from pressure to show a clean balance sheet. A founder wants the loan off the page, and a verbal update feels like enough. The problem is that a verbal status is not evidence, and a status shown on a lender portal may not match the final written decision. Keep the source of each status note in the record, so you can see whether it came from a letter, a portal, or a conversation.<br>
 <br>The fix is a simple decision rule. Say "forgiven" only when you have the written decision and the ledger entry matches it. Otherwise, use plain language such as "application pending," "partially forgiven, with the remaining balance under review," or "denied, with the balance under repayment schedule." Those phrases are less satisfying, but they are accurate, and accuracy protects you more than a clean label does.<br>
 <br>A few steps make the rule easy to follow.<br>
 Replace any verbal status with a document, and file the document with its date.
 Reconcile the ledger, the debt schedule, and the lender's latest statement before any external sharing.
 Disclose open items early, with a plain explanation of what is known and what is still waiting.
 Ask counsel to review any wording that describes the loan in a purchase agreement, investor update, or board report.
 <br>Disclosure works in your favor. A buyer or investor tends to trust a seller or founder who names open items clearly more than one who appears to hide them. An open item that is explained and tracked is a normal part of a business. An open item that is discovered late looks like a problem with the company's controls, even when the underlying loan is in good standing.<br>
 <br>The question from the start still holds: has this loan been forgiven in full, in part, or not at all? If you can answer with a document and a matching entry, you can talk about the loan with confidence. If you cannot, the honest answer is still a good answer, as long as you can show the next step and who owns it.<br>